By Phil Kalas, co-founder, Ashland Leather.
Short answer: The best leather briefcase is the one whose leather, construction and origin you can verify, and that fits your laptop and your day. Compare six things: the leather and how it was tanned, how the bag holds its shape, the hardware and zippers, the lining and layout, where it is cut and sewn, and what the maker will do if it ever comes apart.
I started at Horween® Leather Company in 2006, and we have built leather goods at Ashland in Chicago for 15 years. This guide is the checklist I would use if I were shopping for a briefcase and did not know the maker. It applies to any brand, ours included, and I note where our own briefcases are a good fit and where they are not.
The six things to compare on any leather briefcase
| What to compare | What good looks like | Questions to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Leather | A named leather and tannage, with a finish that suits how you will use it | Which leather is it, who tanned it, and is it a full grain, top grain or split hide? |
| Structure | Stands up on its own, with padding where the laptop sits | What holds the shape: foam, a reinforced base, or heavy leather? |
| Hardware and zippers | Solid metal parts and a known zipper brand | Is the hardware solid brass or plated, and who makes the zippers? |
| Lining and layout | A durable lining and pockets that fit what you carry | Does the sleeve fit your laptop, and where do your charger and phone go? |
| Origin | A clear statement of where it is cut and sewn | Is it designed here and built elsewhere, or built where the maker works? |
| Guarantee | A plain promise from a maker who repairs their own work | What is covered, and who do you send it to? |
Leather: grade and tannage are different questions
Grade describes the part of the hide. Full grain keeps the natural surface of the hide. Top grain has had the surface sanded or corrected. Genuine leather is a broad label that usually means the lower layers of a hide. Our leather grades guide goes through the differences.
Tannage describes how the hide was turned into leather. Vegetable tanning uses tree-bark extracts and takes the longest. Chrome tanning is faster. Combination tanning uses a chrome base with a vegetable retan. Horween® Chromexcel® is combination-tanned and hot-stuffed with oils and waxes, which gives it its pull-up and makes it water-resistant (not waterproof). Horween® Aspen Horsehide carries a casein protein top coat that makes it scratch resistant. Neither tells you the grade, so ask both questions.
A good maker will name the leather and the tannery. If a product page only says "genuine leather" or "luxury leather," keep asking.
Structure: how a briefcase holds its shape
A briefcase that collapses when you set it down is a daily annoyance. Makers solve this in different ways. The LaSalle uses Volara® closed-cell foam between the lining and the leather, which lets it stand upright and gives your laptop a cushion. The Wells uses heavy 6 oz. Chromexcel® with no lining and no foam, so it feels rugged and casual and offers no padding. Both are legitimate choices. They are for different people.
Hardware and zippers
You open a briefcase hundreds of times a year. Look for solid metal parts rather than plated ones, and a zipper brand you recognize. Every metal part on the LaSalle is solid brass, and the zippers are YKK Excella®. We compared hardware from four vendors before choosing.
Lining and layout
The lining is the part that meets laptop corners, keys and chargers. The LaSalle uses Cordura® nylon, which is known for abrasion resistance, plus three internal leather-trimmed pockets, a front quick-access pocket and a leather passthrough that slips over roller luggage handles. Match the layout to what you actually carry, and measure your laptop against the interior sleeve, not the outside of the bag.
Origin: what "made in USA" does and does not tell you
Many well-made briefcases come from workshops outside the United States, and origin alone does not make a bag better. What origin tells you is who you can ask about the leather and the stitching, and whether the people who built it also repair it. "Designed in" is not the same claim as "made in." Ask where the leather is tanned, and where the bag is cut and sewn.
Ours are cut, stitched and finished in our Chicago shop from Horween® leather tanned in Chicago, six-tenths of a mile away. Both founders were Horween® tanners before we made a leather good, and one of us still is. Our Made in USA page explains exactly how we use the term, including what we do not claim.
Guarantee: ask who repairs it
A lifetime promise is only as good as the maker behind it. Our work is Guaranteed for Life: we stand behind the stitching and leather against coming apart under normal use. See the returns and guarantee page for the details.
How the Ashland briefcases compare
| LaSalle | Wells | |
|---|---|---|
| Leather | Horween® Aspen Horsehide, casein top coat, scratch resistant | Horween® Chromexcel® (6 oz.), designed to scuff and develop patina |
| Structure | Volara® foam padding, stands upright | Unlined bucket design, no foam, no dividers |
| Laptop | Padded sleeve, 16.5″ × 10.5″ | Fits a 16″ MacBook Pro, no padded sleeve |
| Pockets | Three internal pockets and a front quick-access pocket | One open main compartment, no dividers |
| Hardware | Solid brass, YKK Excella® zippers | Solid brass, YKK Excella® zippers |
| Size and weight | 17″ × 12″ × 4.5″, 3 lbs | 17″ × 12″ × 4.5″, 3.8 lbs |
| Made | Handcrafted in Chicago | Handcrafted in Chicago |
For the story behind the LaSalle, read how it is built. We also make briefcases in other Horween® leathers, including Shell Cordovan, and you can read why those are different in our Shell Cordovan bags post. Availability changes, so see the leather briefcase collection for what is in the shop now.
When an Ashland briefcase is not the right choice
- You want the lightest possible bag. Leather and structure add weight, and a nylon bag will be lighter.
- You carry a laptop larger than 16 inches. Our sleeve is sized for 16 inch laptops.
- You want many compartments and organizer pockets. The LaSalle has a focused layout, and the Wells is a single open compartment with no dividers.
- You want a messenger, tote or backpack. We do not make those.
If you are still deciding between bag styles, read our leather work bag guide.
Leather briefcase FAQ
What is the best leather for a briefcase?
The best leather is a named one that suits how you carry. Horween® Aspen Horsehide resists scratches. Horween® Chromexcel® builds a rich patina and is water-resistant, not waterproof. Horween® Shell Cordovan is dense and self-polishing. All three are tanned in Chicago.
What is the difference between full grain and top grain leather?
Full grain keeps the natural surface of the hide. Top grain has had the surface sanded or corrected. Genuine leather usually means the lower layers of a hide. Ask the maker which grade and which tannage a briefcase uses.
How long should a leather briefcase last?
A well-built briefcase should last for decades with basic care. That depends on the leather, the stitching, the hardware and the maker's willingness to repair it. Ours are Guaranteed for Life against coming apart under normal use.
How can I tell if a leather briefcase is really made in the USA?
Ask where the leather is tanned and where the bag is cut and sewn. A maker that builds in the USA will say so plainly and tell you how they define it. See our Made in USA page for how we do.
Is a leather briefcase worth it compared with a nylon bag?
If you want a bag that ages well, can be repaired and holds its shape, a leather briefcase is a long-term purchase. If weight and low maintenance matter most, nylon is lighter and simpler.
See the Ashland leather briefcases. Each one is handcrafted in Chicago and Guaranteed for Life.